New Construction
Which Builder Upgrades Are Actually Worth the Money?
From Kelli Salter · Camellia Real Estate Group, brokered by eXp Realty
Pay now for the things you'll hate changing later. Everything else deserves a conversation.
Watch: Which Builder Upgrades Are Actually Worth the Money?
Prefer YouTube? Watch the original video in a new tab.
The design center is where new construction homes can get expensive really fast. It's $800 for this, $2,000 for that, another $3,500 over there.
None of those individual decisions feel enormous until you add them together and realize the house you planned to buy at one price has quietly become a very different financial decision. So when I'm helping someone buy new construction, I have one basic rule: spend your money on the things that will be expensive, disruptive or miserable to change later.
If you're buying a new construction home in South Alabama, your goal shouldn't be to choose every upgrade the builder offers. It should be to spend strategically. Some things I'd absolutely consider paying the builder to do now. Others I'd rather change after closing. And some upgrades may never pay you back financially, but you love them and you'll enjoy them every day. That's okay too. I just want you making those decisions intentionally.
First: anything behind the walls
The first place I want to spend money is on the things that become a much bigger project once the house is finished. Anything structural gets my attention. Anything behind the walls gets my attention. Changing the layout, moving plumbing, adding electrical or wiring, outlets where you know you'll need them, ceiling fan locations, or any decision that gets difficult once the drywall is up: now is the time.
Once those walls are closed, you're not just adding an outlet anymore. Someone may have to open the wall, do the electrical work, repair the drywall, match the texture and repaint. The outlet itself may still be simple. Getting to it just became expensive. Those are exactly the choices I don't want you looking back on six months later wondering why you didn't do them during construction.
Flooring and paint: compare real numbers
Flooring is a little different. Obviously you can replace it later, but think about what later looks like: you already paid for the standard flooring, and now you're paying someone to tear it out while you move furniture and live around installers. So if you already know you'll replace it, let's compare what the builder charges with what it would cost to do later. Sometimes the builder's upgrade is overpriced and we wait. Sometimes doing it during construction makes more sense because we avoid paying for the same thing twice.
Paint is easy to change, but repainting an empty house before you move in is a very different project from repainting after your furniture, TV, curtains, kids and pets are inside. If you can live with the standard paint, save the money. If you already know you'll close on Friday and call the painter on Monday, let's see what the builder charges first. Convenience has value too.
The model home's job is to make you want everything
This is where buyers have to be very careful. You walk in and the lighting is beautiful, the mirrors are perfect, the faucets and cabinet hardware are upgraded, the countertops are prettier than the standard option and every finish works together. Suddenly the standard house feels like a disappointing version. It isn't.
Light fixtures, mirrors, faucets and cabinet hardware are all easy to change, and if you do them later, you aren't limited to the handful of options the builder offers. If the builder wants a substantial premium for a decorative fixture you can easily change after closing, that's where I start asking whether this is really where you want your upgrade budget to go.
Countertops are more involved, but still replaceable after closing without opening walls or changing the structure. If you love the upgraded countertop, you'll enjoy it every day and the price makes sense, go ahead. Just don't feel like this is your only chance to ever have nice countertops.
| Upgrade | My usual approach | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Structural, plumbing, electrical, outlets, fan locations | Strongly consider doing now | Much harder and costlier once the walls are closed |
| Flooring and paint you'll definitely change | Compare the builder's price with doing it later | Avoid paying twice and living through the work |
| Light fixtures, mirrors, faucets, hardware | Usually fine to change later | Easy to swap, with far more choices |
| Countertops | Your call if you love it and the price makes sense | Replaceable later without opening walls |
How a $400,000 house becomes $425,000
Design appointments get tricky because you make a lot of decisions in a short time, and each one is presented individually. It's easy to evaluate each decision by itself. That's why I want us to stop periodically and look at the total.
Say you start with a $400,000 house. We add $5,000, then $7,000, then $3,500, then flooring and countertops, and suddenly we're at $425,000. You're not buying a $400,000 house anymore. Now it's worth stepping back and asking whether we're still making the best real estate decision. At $425,000, maybe a different floor plan, or another builder that includes more of these features as standard, makes more sense. Maybe there's completed inventory with stronger builder incentives. Maybe a resale house at the same price gives you more for your money.
"I don't need to stand beside you and tell you whether I like the tile. I need to help you recognize when a series of small choices has changed the financial decision you're making."
Kelli SalterNot every upgrade is an investment
I don't think you should build your house for some imaginary buyer ten years from now. You're the one who'll live in it. If there's something you love and can comfortably afford, you're allowed to buy it simply because you want it. Just don't call every upgrade an investment. If you spend $8,000 or $10,000 on a very personal design choice, that's completely fine, but don't assume the next buyer will pay you back dollar for dollar. The market will still compare your house with the houses around it, and you can over-improve a new construction home just as easily as an older one.
The upgrades buyers overlook
Everybody wants to talk about countertops. Nobody gets excited about an electrical outlet. But if you already know where your television is going, having power and wiring there will matter every single day. Options that give you better storage, improve the way you use a room or add lighting where you need it may never be why someone falls in love with the house, but they may be why you enjoy living there for the next ten years.
Before the design center, make sure you're happy with the lot. How to choose the right lot covers what to look at, because you can change finishes later, but not where the house sits.
Before your design center appointment
- List what would be a pain to change later: walls, wiring, plumbing, layout
- Price the upgrades you'd otherwise do right after closing
- Separate easy swaps (fixtures, hardware, mirrors) from big projects
- Decide which "just because I love it" items fit your budget
- Keep a running total, and step back if it changes the decision
- Compare the final price with other floor plans, builders and resale homes
Don't start with "what should I upgrade?" Start with what's going to be a pain to change later. That's where your money goes first. Then look at what can reasonably wait, then the things you're choosing simply because you love them. And before you're done, make sure the house still makes financial sense at the new price.
Heading to the design center?
Call us before you start making decisions. We'll look at the house, the builder, the incentives, the upgrades and the total price as one decision instead of 20 separate checkboxes.
